facebook, continued
I’m still thinking about my last post, the one about thinking in Facebook status updates, and it’s brought up new questions. Mainly, is it possible to have meaningful connection with others on Facebook (or Twitter or Instagram or Foursquare or fill-in-the-blank)? Is it possible to nurture a relationship and one’s sense of connectedness online? One of the (many!) things that I hope our boys embrace throughout the course of their lives is meaningful relationships, and I, of course, want to do the same. So I’ve been pondering technology and whether or not it’s conducive to life-giving connection with other people. And I think the answer is a whole-hearted yes… with a caveat.
Let’s look first at the yes. Yes, I do think it is possible and I can think of dozens of examples. Here are just a few…
- As my friend, Donna, commented on the last post, Facebook has been a way for her to remain “in the know” with her friends despite the fact that she is often house-bound with a baby. She can still connect with others, see what they are up to, encourage them and validate them, even if she seldom sees some of them during this particular season in her life.
- Our friend, Greg, known as “Gerg,” passed away a few years ago. He was always a quiet guy, a little shy, and we didn’t think he had a lot of friends. But when he died, a whole slew of online friends came out of the woodwork to share their grief and talk about how much he had meant to them. It was really surprising to me. I had no idea that he had connected with so many people online and that he was part of a virtual community of gamers and coders. Hearing what these online friends said about him left me with no doubt that his connection with them had been real and deeply meaningful.
- When I was pregnant with Gryffin I was approached online by a fellow calligrapher looking for some tips and tricks of the trade. An online friendship was born and the gift my new friend sent me after Gryff was born was one of the most meaningful ones I received. There was such thought and warmth that went into the gift and we are still friends today, though we’ve never met in person.
- With friends and family far away, email and Facebook can serve as a way for us to stay mildly connected over the years and across the miles. Is it the same as being part of one another’s day-to-day life? No. But maintaining those threads of connection, no matter how small, is a good thing, I think. I recently spent an afternoon with a girlfriend from college. We hadn’t seen each other in years but because we’ve maintained a small sense of connection online, it was easier to reconnect and jump back in. It was easily one of the best conversations I’ve had in a really long time.
- This love flash mob that Jason and I joyfully participated in last week. How good it felt to participate with an absolute army of people we’ve never met to make a difference for one woman and her baby.
I’m sure the rest of you have your own examples, your own stories about meaningful connection that you’ve discovered online and I’d enjoy hearing them.
Here’s the caveat, though. I think the problem comes from all the un-meaningful-ness that you can find on Facebook and elsewhere online. All the superfluous… stuff. All the mindless mind-filler. It’s numbing and time-consuming and does absolutely nothing to enrich or edify my life. I think that’s why I sometimes feel lonely and pathetic on Facebook– because I’m not pursuing anything life-giving or beautiful or meaningful. I’m just passing the time, dulling my senses, and taking up time that would be so much better spent elsewhere or in other ways. It DOES go back to being a good steward of the present. I’m multi-tasking instead of uni-tasking, looking at my phone when I should be looking at Jason across the table, I’m pinning recipes instead of preparing a meal with the boys, and compulsively checking email all the day long instead of sitting down to write the one email to a friend that might actually be worth writing. And that’s what’s depressing and lonely.
This technology thing is a fairly new phenomenon and it’s amazing and a whole lot of fun sometimes, but we haven’t had generations blazing the trail before us so that we can learn from their foibles and pitfalls. I’d like to harness all the goodness that the internet and technology have to offer and let the other stuff, the bland and ultimately boring things that fight hard for my attention, fall by the wayside. It’s really not that hard to see which things are important and worth my time and which things aren’t. The hard part is choosing what’s important, don’t you think? I’ve been asking Gryffin and Isaiah lately if they are “making good choices” and I think maybe I could stand to ask myself the same question. Am I choosing real, life-giving, expanding relationships and meaningful connections, online or otherwise, or am I just wasting more and more of my time doing things that don’t really matter?
Great post Nancy! Two things: 1) “gerg” was my cousin. I didn’t know you knew him. That made me smile 🙂 and 2) I did the love flash mob too. Long live Momastery!
I really like what you had to say Nancy. I really value the connections I can keep across distances through Facebook/email/other online venues. Before facebook ever came out, our family joined a site called MyFamily.com, which is basically like facebook for the specific circle you invite to your site, and our family on both sides has been using it for 12 years, including our grandmas. And the friend we just visited in Paris, I’ve been able to keep in touch with over email and facebook through the years. It helps to stay connected between the visits. Jon and I talked about whether or not we wanted to announce our pregnancy on facebook, and ultimately decided we did because we have friends on there that we only really keep in touch with via facebook, and we care about those relationships (though I did go through and do a small “friend” purge before posting the news, which I’ve done from time to time).
On the other hand, one of the negatives of facebook to me is that it’s easy to look at other people’s lives or happenings and become envious or wish you could have been a part of something or done something fun/cool like someone you see. So I guess the flip side of being connected to and aware of others lives is that it can ironically have the ability to make you feel left out, in a sense.
Separately, I read that love flash mob link, and it made me cry. What a cool and inspiring ministry.
Shelly, I had NO idea you were related to Gerg! I showed Jason your picture and he immediately said “oh! I see a family resemblance in her eyes.” Jason worked with Gerg @ Westmont in the IT department and then later @ Brooks as well. He flew down for his funeral. I’m so surprised to hear he was your cousin.
And you’re a monkee, too! I had my suspicions 🙂
Yes, I know just what you mean about feeling left out or envious. That’s spot on.
Great post, Nancy! You bring up important issues about how we use our time, being present, connectedness and relationships in our digital age. It’s a fine line between staying engaged with friends and family scattered around the world and FOMO/Facebragging at the expense of fostering meaningful relationships in the here and now… An important topic that really made me think, so thanks for bringing it up.
Good thoughts Nance, thanks for sharing. As a person who has often used FB for remaining connected while travelling or living far away from family, close friends, even my wife, I think it is much much much better than nothing, but not a substitute for real life contact and connection. Ideally I think we would all live in one big neighborhood and we wouldn’t need wifi or even cell phones to connect…but given what our world looks like I’ll give FB a “like”.
…still looking forward to living in one big neighborhood though…in this life or the next…
great post Nonce! as someone who has often been on the other side of the country or world from people I love, facebook was a revelation to me. in order to communicate some of the small day to day things and some of the bigger things too (but it is the small things that i miss in people’s lives and the small stuff that makes up my own, ya know?) that would never be part of that once-every-few-months skype call, i find it very meaningful to use facebook as a way of filling in some of the gaps of our own life while we far away. ironically, when it comes to tracking with people on facebook, i more than not feel sad to be missing out on all of the happenings of other peoples lives. there is a lot of tension in this for me.
i’ve been reading a book i think you will love as much as me (the moonflower vine) and this quote sort of sums it up, albeit in a rather dramatic fashion, for me. “‘I love you!’ she cried, her voice a hideous squeak, and bolted up the steps-sick with the knowledge that this was how it would be all the rest of her life. She couldn’t stay, but she couldn’t stay away, and she would come back time after time, doomed forever to come and go and endure these ghastly partings. This was the price of her freedom. This was how it was going to be.”